FlashComGuru Home Imediasee Influxis Uvault Akamai
                                                                                       Forum Index | Active Topics | Register
                                                                                                          List Overview | List Archives
                                                                                                                           About this site | Advertise
 

home

Adobe AIR (8)
Applications (32)
Books & Training (9)
Collaboration (8)
Components (6)
Events (49)
Flash Player (8)
Flex (28)
FMS (67)
General (107)
Hosting (5)
Jobs (13)
Off topic (31)
Press Releases (7)
Site Check (7)
Tools (39)
Videos & Players (50)

Flash On the Beach

Alltop, all the cool kids (and me)

 
Warning, rant ahead... It's not very often that I get really annoyed at a piece of software but when it's as important as an operating system than I think it can be expected that it works borderline reliably
People that know me well will testify that you do not hear me swear very often but trust me that this changed dramatically since I upgraded XP to Vista and started to work - tried to work.
The fact of the matter is that Vista rubbish (I'm trying hard to keep my language moderate here). Or let me rephrase that: my install of Vista is rubbish.

Why? Well for starters I can not remember a single blue screen during my time on XP. With Vista (Ultimate) that has changed dramatically and I have had, on one particular day, three seperate stop errors. That meant that at the blink of an eye the whole machine went bam! and I witnesses some cryptic messages in white text on a blue screen. The message also said something about memory being dumped to disk but even that seemed to fail. Needless to say is that any unsaved work was gone and I feel privileged that none of my files were corrupted. Thanks Vista. I think the stop error was somehow related to iTunes and maybe Apple has some blame to take here but the bigger picture seems to point to Vista as this problem was not the only one...
Sorenson Squeeze - it lost all my compression settings after the Vista upgrade. Reinstall it I hear you say. Trust me I tried but unfortunately the installer fails with a very descriptive error:
Error Code: -5004 : 0x80070005 Error Information: >SetupDLL\SetupDLL.cpp (1927) pAPP:Sorenson Squeeze PVENDOR:Sorenson Media, Inc. PGUID:88bfbe72-7e9c-4ded-af1d-1245ace3c213 $7.1.100.1248PAK @Windows (6000) BT_OTHER 0.0

So for now I am Stefan minus Squeeze. I cannot reinstall it on my Vista machine and I don't know why Sorenson tells me it should work.

Then there are the general daily annoyances which any Vista user can testify. For example I use a little backup tool called Handy Backup. Since my Vista upgrade I need to manually allow this to run *everytime* I boot up. It gets better: when I manually select the blocked startup program and click 'allow' it still won't run, oh no. Vista thinks (I presume) that I may have right clicked on a tiny little taskbat icon my mistake, then mistakenly opened the submenu and mistalenly clicked to run the blocked program. And because I'm such a noob I now have to face a blacked out screen via which I have to confirm that I am really sure that I want to run this program... Argh, I need an OS, not a nanny.
I got so annoying that I turned the whole security bollo**s off completely (the technical term for it is User Account Control) and that was not easy but a quick Googling and I was on my unsecure way. Of course it defeats the whole objective of making Windows more secure but quite frankly this is not an OS that can be used for Flash development - its relentless nagging and endless warning dialogues amount to a big old wrench in the gears of my daily work. Terrible. I'm not lying when I say that the experience is exactly like the one below...

Even with the security features enabled you will find yourself (after a few days) simply confirming any dialogue without even reading it properly. Who has time for that? I do not. Either the OS is secure enough to let me get on with my life or it is not in which case it's not my job to make it but that of the manufacturer...
When the OS you have personally installed denies you access to some of your own files then something is not right. If you need to confirm that you really want to open the Services panel after having double clicked its icon a split second earlier then something is not right. When you find yourself unable to revert to XP after a Vista upgrade then something is not right (I couldn't revert, I believe sometimes it can be done though - no, I haven't got time for a clean reinstall right now thank you very much).
I really really would have downgraded to XP if I could have done. That says something about Vista I guess. In fact I cannot think of a single feature that I find better in Vista... I see no productivity gain at all, quite the contrary. The whole machine appears slower than it used to - and that is after I have turned the search indexer off as it was premanently eating CPU and driving my hard disk crazy.
The search in Vista - apparently oh so great and much hyped - but not great enough as it could not find the term 'timer' across the entire directory structure of AS class files when told to search inside files. I guess Vista does not or can not search in AS files, I guess I will never know. Maybe I have forgotten to enable some super secret setting somewhere... Search Indexer is turned off now and that's that. I use Google Desktop instead because it works and always has done.

Final verdict: Vista sucks. I really gave it a good try but I can not live with it, honestly not. It seems to be the same old rubbish under the hood, like an old car that has been giving a respray but the rust is already pushing through again. More rust than ever before in fact. A bodged (if that's even english) repair job.

So what does one do? Well guess what, this is my first blog post written on my new MacBook Pro... And by the way, my chosen version of Windows in Parallels will be XP...

I told you it would be a rant!

Comments
[Add Comment]
Flash and Flex development in OSX has been great; I'm not looking back. Parallels puts windows in it's place, a window.
# Posted By Forrest O. | 5/31/07 10:43 PM
I came to much the same conclusion that you did, but it took me alot longer. I've been running Vista Business since before its public release. At first, I thought it was great...installed perfectly, cool new features, etc. I basically disabled every security control on the O/S hoping that my virus software and other security add-ins would be sufficient to protect me. They were, for the most part. No major incidents. Over time, however, it just seemed like everything was running slower. Booting a server image in VMware started taking an unusually long time (I'm talking 5 to 10 minutes). Processes started hanging, and the Aero interface kept turning itself on and off based on the software I was using and what it was trying to do (Flex is a good example). Ultimately, I realized that I was being made to work too hard to do the same things XP can do without issue. Fortunately, when I installed, I just installed on a secondary partion. I now boot back to the familiar comfort and convenience of XP Pro. That Vista partition will probably rust over before I use it again.

Good Luck Recovering....Truly.

M. McConnell
# Posted By Mike McConnell | 5/31/07 11:03 PM
I'm happy to live in a Mac-world as a graphic designer and webdeveloper since System 7. And VMware makes a PCbox with XP or Vista really obsolete! And yes, they get on my nerves too...
# Posted By Tino Klumpen | 5/31/07 11:09 PM
Your rant is nothing but a reoccurring theme with everyone I've come across having upgraded their machine to Vista. That's why when my pc laptop died two months ago I bought a MacBook Pro. I love it and haven't looked back. Bootcamp + Windows XP (+ Parallels) to run my games, FMS and FME... everything else in OS X. It's insanely fast and installing apps is so easy. Not to mention, and my computer doesn't seem to get sluggish with the more apps I install. My pc's always took a performance hit after I installed my typical applications. Totally diggin Apple now.
# Posted By Brad | 5/31/07 11:48 PM
Come on now guys, let's be honest. We all know that...
1. Windows is the dominant platform, like it or not.
2. Never upgrade a Windows OS without SP1 or higher.
3. Macs have plenty of issues too, they just aren't publicized.

That being said... silverlight must be stopped!
# Posted By Joe | 6/1/07 5:36 AM
I thought I would not be on my own...
Joe, the fact that Windows is dominant does not say anything about its quality. And I have no real problem with Windows as such, but Vista really hasn't lived up to its expectations for me.
# Posted By Stefan | 6/1/07 8:25 AM
The ideas behind Vista are correct I think, but in the real world people are just way more productive with XP.
# Posted By Jan Pies | 6/1/07 12:57 PM
I put Vista on my gaming PC and 3 days later wiped the harddrive to put XP back on. Then I just bought a mac to replace my old HP work laptop because I refuse to buy a new system with a crap operating system.
# Posted By Jamie | 6/1/07 2:21 PM
I think a better title woule be the return of Windows ME 2 (Vistia)
Does any one have a picture of bill gates holding a dollar bill with his MAC behind him ?
# Posted By win xp user | 6/4/07 1:36 AM
I'm using vista and the two first week were a pain in the a**. I couldn't install QuickTime and MSN. Kind of funny it toke MS a month to fix the MSN issue.

All the other app work fine. Flash Pro 8 compile even faster(well I had to get a new pc to run vista, it could be that)!
# Posted By Guillaume M. | 6/4/07 2:21 PM
LOL, yeah apparently Vista really comes to life once you add 4GB of RAM! :-)
# Posted By Stefan | 6/4/07 2:23 PM
Well Guys you know you should never install any MS OS until the beta test with the public has run its course. Vista will be very stable in the 3rd quarter of 2008 or mid 2009
# Posted By aYo | 6/4/07 3:46 PM
Same here. Windows Vista lasted 36 hours with me before I figured I lost my upgrade fee. I am back on XP. It appears also that Microsoft is doing everything it can to thwart Adobe, Google and others from making anymore headway. Expect more problems in the future!
# Posted By Randy MIller | 6/26/07 10:07 AM
hehe and it's getting worse here at my end. iTunes is still on occasions bringing down my Vista system with some nasty STOP errors, Outlook always throws an error on startup now, network connections need to be reset after every boot... the list goes on.
I'm slowly transitioning to my Mac but it will take some time. I can see a Mac Pro coming up as soon as funds allow.
# Posted By Stefan | 6/26/07 10:12 AM
Oh yea! I also have brand new HP with Blu-ray burner and the whole nine yards with 4GB Ram and core duo and nope. Vista runs slow on that too! But I have left it on that machine for the time being because HP does not support DOWNGRADES! Which means no Blu-ray driver, etc. If I put on a copy of XP and ditch Vista on that machine. Can anyone say APOLLO is about to kill Microsoft?
# Posted By Randy MIller | 6/26/07 10:12 AM
Have you found a fix for Squeeze yet? I'm having the same problem
# Posted By Wout | 7/2/07 12:45 AM
hi Wout,
nope sorry, I'm still without Squeeze...
# Posted By Stefan | 7/2/07 9:14 AM
Stefan, Sorenson got back to me on my support ticket! Version 4.5.5 (free upgrade) fixes the problem.

http://www.sorensonmedia.com/pages/?pageID=8
# Posted By Wout | 7/2/07 8:55 PM
I do not know how old you are but you all just sounds like old geezer that wont upgrade because we burst their bubbles and that a certain program does not run like the previous one, remember seing same time over and over for 3.1 to 95 to 98 to 98me to XP and now Vista.. full circle again
# Posted By jplyn | 7/5/07 12:52 PM
Ditched Win98 a couple years ago. Got a Macmini. Just got one of those new Asus eee701 ultraportables (Xandros Linux). Nice bit of kit. Looking to get one of the newer faster Macs with the upgraded predator under the hood.
Enjoy.
# Posted By Tim Fuller | 1/7/08 3:04 AM